Why Meta Treats Similar Ads as One Ad (and How to Fix It) — Digital Shahbaz

Why Meta Treats Similar Ads as One Ad (and How to Fix It)

November 17, 2026•4 min read

Last updated: 17 November 2026

Quick answer

Meta appears to group ads that look or feel very similar and treat them as one option. Practitioners call this an "Entity ID." Meta has not documented it officially, but its new Creative Diversity rating points the same way. The fix: replace near-copies with ads that differ in format, angle and buyer, not just the hook.

Why is Meta spending on only one of my ads?

This is one of the most common complaints from Indian advertisers: "I uploaded 6 ads and Meta spent 90% on one." Two things are usually going on.

  1. Meta is doing its job. It sends more budget to the ad it predicts will get results. One clear winner is normal.
  2. Your other ads may not be different enough to count. If 5 of your 6 ads are the same video with small edits, Meta may treat them as one option. The losers were never really tested as separate ideas.

What is a Meta "Entity ID"?

Advertisers widely report that Meta groups visually or thematically similar ads under a shared identifier and treats them as one option. People call it an Entity ID. Meta has not documented it, so the idea is inferred from how delivery behaves (PPC Land).

What Meta has done is add a Creative Diversity rating in Ads Manager (Low, Medium or High) that scores how similar the ads in an ad set are (Common Thread Collective). Whatever the exact mechanism, the message is the same: similar ads don't add new options.

Be careful with exact numbers you see online, such as "ads become one entity above 60% similarity." Meta has not published a threshold. Treat those figures as guesses.

Which edits do NOT make a new ad?

In my experience, and in what most Meta experts report, these usually don't count as a new idea:

  • A new hook text on the same video
  • A different background colour or font
  • The same video in a different crop
  • A different CTA button
  • The same image with a new headline

Which changes DO make a new ad?

  • A different format: talking video vs carousel vs static vs screen recording
  • A different person on camera: you vs a student vs a customer
  • A different angle or pain point: interviews vs client calls vs confidence
  • A different setting: office vs home vs outdoor
  • A different language: Hindi vs Hinglish vs English

The 20-minute audit

  1. Open your last 20 ads in Ads Manager, sorted by spend.
  2. Write one line per ad: what it says and what you see. Example: "Coach talking, interview fear."
  3. Group identical lines. Each group is likely one idea in Meta's eyes.
  4. Count your real ideas. 20 ads in 4 groups = 4 ideas.
  5. Check the Creative Diversity rating for each ad set.
  6. Take your best-performing group and turn its message into 3 different formats. One expert newsletter we reviewed recommends exactly this: keep the winning angle, change the format.
  7. Pause the near-copies that never got spend. They are not adding anything.

Worked example: a fitness coach in Pune

Illustrative, not a client case.

Before: 8 ads. All reels of the coach in the gym, with 8 different hook texts. Meta spends almost everything on one. The coach thinks "7 hooks failed."

What actually happened: Meta probably saw one idea. The 7 "losers" were never separate tests.

After: 4 ideas, same budget.

  1. Gym reel: "Shaadi se pehle 8 kg kam" (pain: wedding deadline)
  2. Client before/after carousel (proof)
  3. Static: "₹1,999 mein 30-day home plan, no gym" (offer: home)
  4. Screen recording of the diet plan app (format: demo)

₹ Reality Check: what I'd do with ₹1,000/day

My view, not a guarantee of results.

  • Never more than 2 ads that share the same visual
  • 4–5 ideas, each from a different group
  • When one idea wins, make 2 new formats of that idea, and keep the original running

The PMS lens

  • Psychology: different people respond to different reasons. Similar ads only test one reason.
  • Measurement: "6 ads, 1 got spend" is not a test result. Count ideas, not ads.
  • Systems: run the 20-minute audit every 2 weeks.

Related: Meta Andromeda Update 2026 · Andromeda Creative Diversity

FAQ

Does Meta officially group similar ads?

Meta has not documented an Entity ID. But practitioners widely report it, and Meta's Creative Diversity rating measures how similar your ads are.

Why does Meta spend all my budget on one ad?

Partly because it predicts that ad will win, and partly because your other ads may be too similar to count as separate options.

Is changing the hook enough to make a new creative?

Usually not. Change the format, person, angle, setting or language.

Should I duplicate my winning ad?

No. A duplicate adds nothing new. Make a different version of the winning message instead.

How many different ads do I need?

On a small Indian budget, 3–5 genuinely different ideas per ad set.


About the author: Shahbaz Shaikh (Digital Shahbaz) is a Meta ads expert in India who has managed ₹30Cr+ in Meta ad spend for coaches, consultants and edtech brands, and has trained 5,000+ marketers. Work with Shahbaz.

Next step: Book a DigiMark account audit, or join the ₹99 Meta Ads Masterclass.

Digital Shahbaz

Digital Shahbaz

Shahbaz Shaikh is the founder of DigiMark Media and creator of Digital Shahbaz. He has personally audited 500+ Meta Ads accounts, managed over ₹30 Cr in ad spend across 300+ clients, and trained 2,500+ marketers across India. He teaches the PMS Framework — Psychology, Measurement, Systems — the same system he uses to run campaigns for his own clients.

Back to Blog
Shahbaz Shaikh
WRITTEN BY Shahbaz Shaikh · Marketing Engineer

Founder of DigiMark Media, MEX Academy and Kairoas. ₹30Cr+ in Meta ad spend managed, 300+ clients served and 5,000+ marketers trained. I write about the systems behind predictable revenue — words, numbers and systems.

Want the full system, live?

In 90 minutes, I'll show you the exact AI + Meta Ads system behind these articles. Free. Live. In Hindi + English.

LIVE EVERY WEEK · 100% FREE · SEATS ARE LIMITED
Digital Shahbaz icon Digital Shahbaz

Marketing Engineer. I build and teach the Meta Ads, funnel and AI systems that turn ads into predictable revenue.

CONTACT [email protected] Gujarat, India

Results shown are from real clients and students. They are not typical and not a guarantee. Your results depend on your effort, offer, market and execution.

This site is not a part of the Facebook™ website or Meta Platforms, Inc. Additionally, this site is not endorsed by Facebook™ in any way. FACEBOOK™ is a trademark of Meta Platforms, Inc.

© 2026 Digital Shahbaz. All rights reserved. PrivacyTermsRefund PolicyDisclaimer